Posts

Showing posts from September, 2020

The theology of Sausage Party

Image
It is enough to look at the ~2minutes of the trailer for Sausage Party to realize it is one crass, raunchy, silly comedy. For all its juvenile humor, it also gets enough critics puzzled enough that the rottentomatoes critical consensus is about its good gag-to-laugh ratio and thought provoking story-line. And there's something to that, I think. So buckle up, we're going to use a stoner comedy to explore theology. --:-- Let's first summarize the plot. Spoiler alert, obviously, though the trailer reveals the basic premise anyway: food items are conscious. They wait on the shelves of the supermarket to be picked up by the gods, and carried to some better place where "nothing bad ever happens to food", as their song goes. Well, something bad does happen to food once it reaches the home of the gods obviously. Those "gods", well, us, they eat the food. And they slice it, dice it, boil it -- even the children -- and do all sorts of unpleasant things to it. On...

A view on Moldbug from the other Red side

I mentioned in my previous post that I encountered an analysis of American politics about which I wanted a response from people who had lived under communism, such as my parents. That American analysis, a summary more like, is an hour long video and deserves a critique on its own terms (SOON(TM)). This is not that critique, it's simply a view from a different part of history that I thought would be interesting. Since the video is rather long, I'll try to summarize the main points first, so that we know what we compare against. There are a few general historical and philosophical ideas in it, but for now the pertinent ones are more tightly concerned with the USA and how it is run. The video's author, The Distributist, in summarizing Moldbug, claims political power in America has a strong informal component: it is not so much the governing party that really is in charge. Politics is downstream from culture, and culture is shaped by elites working in journalism, in universit...

Translation -- not betrayal but examination

I like to think that people who see me post on CritiqueCircle would be surprised to learn English is my second language. I would boast even more -- I think in English, though, perhaps, this is less surprising since the language I interact with most in my profession, and for a good portion of my leisure time, is English. At some point thoughts themselves will start following its haggard strings of consonants . I think my boast is based on truth, but even so, or rather because of this belief, I found cause for surprise in a little translation I undertook recently.  I had watched a video from The Distributist several times over the past year or so, a bit more in recent times. The video itself deserves a post or two to discuss, but this is not that post. Sufficient to say, I found it an interesting, but very "American" perspective on things. What would someone who had lived under communism think of it? What would my father think of it? But of course here was the problem: the vi...